Placers
Places 1 to 8 as the record has them.
Championship
Round of 32 · 3 bouts
- Al DeLeon, Minnesota-Mankato over Jim Valentine, Ithaca (NY) — Dec 8–4 · View bout
- Joe DiBella, Coast Guard (CT) over John McCrillis, Iowa State — Dec 7–4 · View bout
- Larry Lauchle (2), Pittsburgh (PA) over John Kelly, Iowa — Dec 6–4 · View bout
Round of 16 · 8 bouts
- Gary Hoagland (4), Portland State (OR) over Joe DiBella, Coast Guard (CT) — Dec 8–2 · View bout
- Jerry Headington, Utah over Gordon Danks, Penn State — Dec 6–5 · View bout
- Lanny Bryant (3), Northern Colorado over Ed Cliatt, Maryland — Dec 5–3 · View bout
- Larry Lauchle (2), Pittsburgh (PA) over Franc Freeman, Northern Iowa — Dec 3–0 · View bout
- Norm Young (6), Michigan State over Bill Kehrig, Lycoming (PA) — Dec 5–1 · View bout
- Ramon West (5), Rochester Tech (NY) over Doug Baillie, Lehigh (PA) — Dec 6–2 · View bout
- Ron Hutcherson, Indiana (IN) over Bill Corn, Western Colorado — Dec 6–2 · View bout
- Stan Abel (1), Oklahoma over Al DeLeon, Minnesota-Mankato — Dec 6–1 · View bout
Quarterfinal · 4 bouts
- Larry Lauchle (2), Pittsburgh (PA) over Jerry Headington, Utah — Dec 8–2 · View bout
- Norm Young (6), Michigan State over Lanny Bryant (3), Northern Colorado — Fall 8:37 · View bout
- Ramon West (5), Rochester Tech (NY) over Gary Hoagland (4), Portland State (OR) — Dec 4–0 · View bout
- Stan Abel (1), Oklahoma over Ron Hutcherson, Indiana (IN) — Dec 9–5 · View bout
Semifinal · 2 bouts
- Larry Lauchle (2), Pittsburgh (PA) over Norm Young (6), Michigan State — Dec 4–0 · View bout
- Stan Abel (1), Oklahoma over Ramon West (5), Rochester Tech (NY) — Dec 9–4 · View bout
Final · 1 bout
- Stan Abel (1), Oklahoma over Larry Lauchle (2), Pittsburgh (PA) — Dec 5–2 · View bout
Consolation
Consolation round 4 · 1 bout
- John Kelly, Iowa over Franc Freeman, Northern Iowa — Dec 4–2 · View bout
Consolation round 5 · 2 bouts
- John Kelly, Iowa over Jerry Headington, Utah — Dec 4–2 · View bout
- Ron Hutcherson, Indiana (IN) over Al DeLeon, Minnesota-Mankato — Dec 10–9 · View bout
Consolation semifinal · 2 bouts
- John Kelly, Iowa over Norm Young (6), Michigan State — Dec 1–0 · View bout
- Ron Hutcherson, Indiana (IN) over Ramon West (5), Rochester Tech (NY) — Dec 6–5 · View bout
Placement bouts
3rd-place bout · 1 bout
- John Kelly, Iowa over Ron Hutcherson, Indiana (IN) — MFF · View bout
Bouts as the source workbook records them, in round order. No bracket positions or byes are inferred.