1958 NCAA Championships
Individual championship awards, preserved source match rows, independently reviewed bracket topology where available, and team standings reconstructed from the recorded match rows under the era’s scoring rules, reconciled against the NCAA’s published totals. This page does not infer official individual placements.
Individual champions
| Weight | Champion | Program | Evidence | Final |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 115 | Dick Delgado | Oklahoma | Source final | Recorded final |
| 123 | Paul Powell | Pittsburgh (PA) | Source final | Recorded final |
| 130 | Leslie Anderson | Iowa State | Source final | Recorded final |
| 137 | Paul Aubrey | Oklahoma | Source final | Recorded final |
| 147 | Ron Gray | Iowa State | Source final | Recorded final |
| 157 | Dick Beattie | Oklahoma State | Source final | Recorded final |
| 167 | Duane Murty | Oklahoma State | Source final | Recorded final |
| 177 | Gary Kurdelmeier | Iowa | Source final | Recorded final |
| 191 | Ken Maidlow | Michigan State | Source final | Recorded final |
| Unlimited | Bob Norman | Illinois | Source final | Recorded final |
Team standings (reconstructed)
Points are recomputed from this year’s recorded match rows under the 1956 rule set: advancement (including bye advancement), bonus, and guaranteed-place increments, plus any curated adjustments. 51 of 51 program-years match the NCAA Division I Wrestling Championships Records Book totals exactly.
Published standings: NCAA Division I Wrestling Championships Records Book, All-Time Team Results, 1958. Programs the book lists without an archive entry that year are not shown.
Recorded matches
Results remain grouped by the archive’s documented round display order unless a weight links to a verified, approved bracket. Source round counts alone do not establish advancement routes.
| Year | Round | Recorded sides | Method | Recorded seeds | Match link |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 115 | |||||
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Chuck Prunty vs Keith Shrock | Dec 8–2 | 0 · recorded zero / No. 4 | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Dick Delgado vs Juno Uyematsu | Fall 5:59 | No. 1 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Frank Altman vs Dante Shapiro | Dec 7–0 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Larry Guldberg vs Art McCall | Dec 10–7 | 0 · recorded zero / No. 6 | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | Bob Taylor vs Frank Altman | Dec 8–5 | No. 2 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | Dick Delgado vs John 'Jack' Thamert | Fall 5:22 | No. 1 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | Gene Williams vs Chuck Prunty | Dec 9–7 | No. 5 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | Ray Osborne vs Larry Guldberg | Dec 6–3 | No. 3 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Semifinal Champ 4 | Bob Taylor vs Ray Osborne | Dec | No. 2 / No. 3 | Open |
| 1958 | Semifinal Champ 4 | Dick Delgado vs Gene Williams | Fall 6:40 | No. 1 / No. 5 | Open |
| 1958 | Championship final 1st | Dick Delgado vs Bob Taylor | Dec 8–3 | No. 1 / No. 2 | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #1 | Juno Uyematsu vs John 'Jack' Thamert | Dec 3–2 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #2 | Frank Altman vs Ray Osborne | Dec 3–0 | 0 · recorded zero / No. 3 | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #2 | Gene Williams vs Juno Uyematsu | Dec 9–4 | No. 5 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Third-place bout 3rd | Gene Williams vs Frank Altman | Dec 0–0 | No. 5 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 123 | |||||
| 1958 | Round of 32 Champ 32 | Ray Haney vs George Munnich | Dec 4–2 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Bob Herald vs Alvin Christie | Dec 10–4 | No. 4 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Don Bernard vs Dick Mueller | Dec 5–2 | 0 · recorded zero / No. 2 | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Frank Jordan vs Dave Auble | Dec 6–5 | 0 · recorded zero / No. 3 | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Joel Neuschwander vs Leonard Shelton | Dec 7–4 | No. 6 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | John Johnston vs Jim Miller | Dec 5–1 | No. 1 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Larry Moser vs Sal Archuleta | FF | No. 5 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Paul Powell vs Harold Simonek | Dec 5–3 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Ray Haney vs John Wager | Dec 3–2 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | Bob Herald vs Larry Moser | Dec 4–3 | No. 4 / No. 5 | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | Joel Neuschwander vs Frank Jordan | Dec 3–1 | No. 6 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | John Johnston vs Ray Haney | Dec 4–2 | No. 1 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | Paul Powell vs Don Bernard | Dec 7–4 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Semifinal Champ 4 | Bob Herald vs John Johnston | Dec 4–3 | No. 4 / No. 1 | Open |
| 1958 | Semifinal Champ 4 | Paul Powell vs Joel Neuschwander | Dec 9–4 | 0 · recorded zero / No. 6 | Open |
| 1958 | Championship final 1st | Paul Powell vs Bob Herald | Dec 11–4 | 0 · recorded zero / No. 4 | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #1 | Don Bernard vs Harold Simonek | Fall 9:56 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #1 | Larry Moser vs Alvin Christie | Dec 5–1 | No. 5 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #2 | Don Bernard vs Joel Neuschwander | Dec 5–0 | 0 · recorded zero / No. 6 | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #2 | John Johnston vs Larry Moser | Dec 2–0 | No. 1 / No. 5 | Open |
| 1958 | Third-place bout 3rd | John Johnston vs Don Bernard | Dec 3–0 | No. 1 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 130 | |||||
| 1958 | Round of 32 Champ 32 | John Kelly vs Joe Dewey Jr. | Fall 5:24 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 32 Champ 32 | Lynn Griffith vs Allen Cutsforth | Dec 7–1 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 32 Champ 32 | Ted Pierce vs Rex Whitlatch | Dec 7–5 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Carmen Molino vs John Kelly | Dec 4–1 | No. 4 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Dale Madden vs Jim Stone | Dec 2–0 | 0 · recorded zero / No. 5 | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Don Stroud vs Dick Van Auken | Dec 3–1 | No. 3 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Leslie Anderson vs Jerry Headington | Dec 9–6 | No. 2 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Max Pearson vs Garth Rogers | Dec 10–3 | No. 1 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Stan Abel vs Lynn Griffith | Dec 8–5 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Ted Pierce vs Clarence McNair | Dec 5–3 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Vic DeFelice vs John Vovos | Dec 6–4 | No. 6 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | Carmen Molino vs Dale Madden | Dec 9–4 | No. 4 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | Leslie Anderson vs Ted Pierce | Dec 4–2 | No. 2 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | Max Pearson vs Stan Abel | Dec 11–7 | No. 1 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | Vic DeFelice vs Don Stroud | Dec 6–5 | No. 6 / No. 3 | Open |
| 1958 | Semifinal Champ 4 | Leslie Anderson vs Vic DeFelice | Dec 4–2 | No. 2 / No. 6 | Open |
| 1958 | Semifinal Champ 4 | Max Pearson vs Carmen Molino | Dec 5–1 | No. 1 / No. 4 | Open |
| 1958 | Championship final 1st | Leslie Anderson vs Max Pearson | Dec 7–5 | No. 2 / No. 1 | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #1 | Stan Abel vs Garth Rogers | Dec 6–0 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #1 | Ted Pierce vs Jerry Headington | Dec 8–2 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #2 | Stan Abel vs Carmen Molino | Dec 4–2 | 0 · recorded zero / No. 4 | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #2 | Ted Pierce vs Vic DeFelice | Dec 3–1 | 0 · recorded zero / No. 6 | Open |
| 1958 | Third-place bout 3rd | Stan Abel vs Ted Pierce | Dec 6–4 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 137 | |||||
| 1958 | Round of 32 Champ 32 | Dick Santoro vs Don Morrison | Dec 12–4 | No. 2 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 32 Champ 32 | Guy Guccione vs Ben Lloyd | Dec 8–2 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 32 Champ 32 | Lee Grubbs vs Dick Storch | Fall 8:48 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 32 Champ 32 | Paul Aubrey vs Wilbur Bauer | Dec 7–3 | No. 6 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 32 Champ 32 | Shelby Wilson vs Tom Winder | Dec 12–4 | No. 1 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Carl Scott vs Charles 'Kent' Chamberlain | Dec 2–2 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Dean Corner vs Bill Morris | Fall 2:49 | No. 5 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Dick Santoro vs Joe Heller | Dec 8–1 | No. 2 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Gene Luttrell vs Lee Grubbs | Dec 6–2 | No. 4 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Joe Hammaker vs Guy Guccione | Dec 5–3 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Paul Aubrey vs Max Mitchell | Dec 5–0 | No. 6 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Shelby Wilson vs Jerry Lane | Dec 8–3 | No. 1 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Tom Hall vs Tim Boudreaux | Dec 5–1 | No. 3 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | Dean Corner vs Gene Luttrell | Dec 4–0 | No. 5 / No. 4 | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | Dick Santoro vs Carl Scott | Dec 6–3 | No. 2 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | Paul Aubrey vs Tom Hall | Dec 5–3 | No. 6 / No. 3 | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | Shelby Wilson vs Joe Hammaker | Dec 14–5 | No. 1 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Semifinal Champ 4 | Paul Aubrey vs Dick Santoro | Dec 5–3 | No. 6 / No. 2 | Open |
| 1958 | Semifinal Champ 4 | Shelby Wilson vs Dean Corner | Dec 5–0 | No. 1 / No. 5 | Open |
| 1958 | Championship final 1st | Paul Aubrey vs Shelby Wilson | Dec 11–9 | No. 6 / No. 1 | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 8 #2 | Jerry Lane vs Tom Winder | Dec 6–4 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 8 #2 | Wilbur Bauer vs Max Mitchell | Dec 7–3 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #1 | Joe Hammaker vs Jerry Lane | Dec 6–5 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #1 | Tom Hall vs Wilbur Bauer | Fall 1:39 | No. 3 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #2 | Dick Santoro vs Tom Hall | Dec | No. 2 / No. 3 | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #2 | Joe Hammaker vs Dean Corner | Dec 3–2 | 0 · recorded zero / No. 5 | Open |
| 1958 | Third-place bout 3rd | Dick Santoro vs Joe Hammaker | Dec 4–3 | No. 2 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 147 | |||||
| 1958 | Round of 32 Champ 32 | Earl Dearing vs Jerry Knight | Dec 5–1 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 32 Champ 32 | Jack Anderson vs Jim Cooper | Dec 8–5 | No. 4 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 32 Champ 32 | Joe Gratto vs Howard Reminick | Dec 4–0 | No. 2 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 32 Champ 32 | Nick Biondi vs Charles Douglas | Dec | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 32 Champ 32 | Pete Jones vs Sherman 'Marvin' Vandevender | Dec 6–2 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 32 Champ 32 | Ron Gray vs Jerry Canfield | Fall 3:30 | No. 3 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Dick Vincent vs Jack Anderson | Dec 7–4 | 0 · recorded zero / No. 4 | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Earl Dearing vs Simon Roberts | Dec 6–2 | 0 · recorded zero / No. 1 | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Joe Gratto vs Lyle Neville | Fall 7:06 | No. 2 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Nick Biondi vs Chuck Patten | Dec 8–7 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Nick Petronka vs Phil Kresge | Dec 8–2 | No. 6 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Pete Jones vs Henry Shaw | Dec 8–4 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Ron Gray vs Jim Miller | Dec 6–0 | No. 3 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Werner Holzer vs Larry Gregory | Dec 5–0 | No. 5 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | Dick Vincent vs Werner Holzer | Dec 7–3 | 0 · recorded zero / No. 5 | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | Earl Dearing vs Nick Biondi | Dec 3–0 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | Joe Gratto vs Pete Jones | Dec 8–5 | No. 2 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | Ron Gray vs Nick Petronka | Dec 3–0 | No. 3 / No. 6 | Open |
| 1958 | Semifinal Champ 4 | Dick Vincent vs Earl Dearing | Fall 9:57 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Semifinal Champ 4 | Ron Gray vs Joe Gratto | Dec 5–2 | No. 3 / No. 2 | Open |
| 1958 | Championship final 1st | Ron Gray vs Dick Vincent | Dec 6–2 | No. 3 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 8 #2 | Jerry Canfield vs Jim Miller | Fall 3:38 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #1 | Jack Anderson vs Werner Holzer | Dec 7–6 | No. 4 / No. 5 | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #1 | Nick Petronka vs Jerry Canfield | Dec 6–2 | No. 6 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #2 | Jack Anderson vs Earl Dearing | Dec 10–0 | No. 4 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #2 | Nick Petronka vs Joe Gratto | Dec 4–3 | No. 6 / No. 2 | Open |
| 1958 | Third-place bout 3rd | Jack Anderson vs Nick Petronka | Dec 5–0 | No. 4 / No. 6 | Open |
| 157 | |||||
| 1958 | Round of 32 Champ 32 | Bill Gabbard vs John Driscoll | Dec 3–2 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 32 Champ 32 | Burt Burger vs Dick Godfrey | Dec 3–0 | No. 6 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 32 Champ 32 | Dick Beattie vs Gusav Gleiter | Dec 8–0 | No. 1 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 32 Champ 32 | Dick Heaton vs Everett McGlothlin | Dec 7–3 | No. 5 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 32 Champ 32 | Jim Beaton vs Jim Gass | Dec 8–4 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 32 Champ 32 | John Doyle vs Jim Reifsteck | Dec 9–5 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 32 Champ 32 | Ken Schiess vs Bill Reiners | Dflt | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 32 Champ 32 | Sid Terry vs Jim Wirtz | Dec 4–1 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 32 Champ 32 | Stan Lampe vs Tom Halford | Fall 3:24 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Dale Ketelsen vs Bill Gabbard | Dec 6–2 | No. 3 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Dick Beattie vs Stan Lampe | Dec 4–2 | No. 1 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Dick Heaton vs George Gray | Dec 5–0 | No. 5 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Fred Brownlee vs Burt Burger | Dec 3–0 | 0 · recorded zero / No. 6 | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Jim Beaton vs Carl Goodwin | Dec 7–4 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | John Doyle vs Dave Johnson | Dec 4–3 | 0 · recorded zero / No. 2 | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Sid Terry vs Bob Moser | Fall 2:17 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Steve Friedman vs Ken Schiess | Dec 11–4 | No. 4 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | Dale Ketelsen vs Fred Brownlee | Dec 3–2 | No. 3 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | Dick Beattie vs Sid Terry | Dec 7–3 | No. 1 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | Dick Heaton vs Steve Friedman | Dec 4–0 | No. 5 / No. 4 | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | Jim Beaton vs John Doyle | Dec 3–2 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Semifinal Champ 4 | Dale Ketelsen vs Jim Beaton | Dec 7–1 | No. 3 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Semifinal Champ 4 | Dick Beattie vs Dick Heaton | Dec 4–1 | No. 1 / No. 5 | Open |
| 1958 | Championship final 1st | Dick Beattie vs Dale Ketelsen | Dec 2–2 | No. 1 / No. 3 | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 8 #2 | Stan Lampe vs Gusav Gleiter | Dec 7–4 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #1 | Bill Gabbard vs Fred Brownlee | Dec 2–1 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #1 | Stan Lampe vs Sid Terry | Dec 5–0 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #2 | Bill Gabbard vs Jim Beaton | Dec 4–2 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #2 | Dick Heaton vs Stan Lampe | Dec 5–3 | No. 5 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Third-place bout 3rd | Bill Gabbard vs Dick Heaton | Dec 3–2 | 0 · recorded zero / No. 5 | Open |
| 167 | |||||
| 1958 | Round of 32 Champ 32 | Dick Swerdfeger vs Bernard Sullivan | Dec | 0 · recorded zero / No. 4 | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 32 Champ 32 | Duane Murty vs Gary Burdick | Dec 7–1 | No. 3 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 32 Champ 32 | Fred Pitzner vs Gerry Gienger | Dec 8–2 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 32 Champ 32 | Ray McGuire vs Ken Spagnola | Dec 4–1 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Bill Wright vs Fred Pitzner | Dec 6–3 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Dick Ballinger vs Alex Skirpan | Fall 4:09 | No. 1 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Dick Swerdfeger vs Bob Foster | Dec 2–1 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Duane Murty vs George Krupicka | Dec 4–2 | No. 3 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Ellie Watkins vs Ray McGuire | Dec 3–1 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Jim Ferguson vs Ken Koenig | Dec 2–0 | 0 · recorded zero / No. 5 | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Ralph DiMuccio vs Fred Ford | Dec 3–2 | No. 6 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Roy Minter vs Bob Riehm | Dec 4–3 | No. 2 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | Dick Ballinger vs Bill Wright | Dec 8–2 | No. 1 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | Duane Murty vs Ralph DiMuccio | Dec 9–3 | No. 3 / No. 6 | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | Jim Ferguson vs Dick Swerdfeger | Dec 3–0 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | Roy Minter vs Ellie Watkins | Dec 2–2 | No. 2 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Semifinal Champ 4 | Dick Ballinger vs Jim Ferguson | Dec 2–1 | No. 1 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Semifinal Champ 4 | Duane Murty vs Roy Minter | Dec 4–3 | No. 3 / No. 2 | Open |
| 1958 | Championship final 1st | Duane Murty vs Dick Ballinger | Dec 4–2 | No. 3 / No. 1 | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 8 #2 | George Krupicka vs Gary Burdick | Dec 6–3 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #1 | Bill Wright vs Alex Skirpan | Dec 9–6 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #1 | George Krupicka vs Ralph DiMuccio | Dec 6–4 | 0 · recorded zero / No. 6 | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #2 | Jim Ferguson vs Bill Wright | Dec 2–0 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #2 | Roy Minter vs George Krupicka | Dec 1–0 | No. 2 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Third-place bout 3rd | Jim Ferguson vs Roy Minter | Dec 4–2 | 0 · recorded zero / No. 2 | Open |
| 177 | |||||
| 1958 | Round of 32 Champ 32 | Bob Benson Sr. vs Tom Burruss | Fall 7:06 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 32 Champ 32 | Frank Powell vs Lee Ramage | Dec 5–0 | No. 1 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 32 Champ 32 | Pete Davidson vs Glenn Payne | Dec 10–4 | No. 5 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 32 Champ 32 | Russ Camilleri vs John Nowlin Sr. | Dec 3–1 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Dick Dean vs Al Blanshan | Dec 5–4 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Frank Fiore vs Colbert Pepper | Dec 9–2 | No. 6 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Frank Powell vs Lee Ramage | Dec 8–2 | No. 1 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Gary Haller vs George Alfredson | Dec 5–2 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Gary Kurdelmeier vs Ed Rath | Dec 7–4 | No. 4 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | George 'Tim' Woodin vs Russ Camilleri | Fall 5:04 | No. 2 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | John Dustin vs Bob Benson Sr. | Dec 7–3 | No. 3 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Merv Miller vs Pete Davidson | Dec 10–9 | 0 · recorded zero / No. 5 | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | Frank Powell vs Dick Dean | Dec 9–3 | No. 1 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | Gary Kurdelmeier vs Merv Miller | Dec 7–0 | No. 4 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | George 'Tim' Woodin vs Gary Haller | Fall 3:52 | No. 2 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | John Dustin vs Frank Fiore | Dec 6–1 | No. 3 / No. 6 | Open |
| 1958 | Semifinal Champ 4 | Gary Kurdelmeier vs Frank Powell | Dec 6–4 | No. 4 / No. 1 | Open |
| 1958 | Semifinal Champ 4 | George 'Tim' Woodin vs John Dustin | Dec 3–0 | No. 2 / No. 3 | Open |
| 1958 | Championship final 1st | Gary Kurdelmeier vs George 'Tim' Woodin | Dec 6–2 | No. 4 / No. 2 | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #1 | Ed Rath vs Merv Miller | Fall 5:31 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #1 | Russ Camilleri vs Gary Haller | Fall 4:46 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #2 | Frank Powell vs Ed Rath | Dec 6–1 | No. 1 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #2 | John Dustin vs Russ Camilleri | Dec 2–1 | No. 3 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Third-place bout 3rd | Frank Powell vs John Dustin | Dec 6–0 | No. 1 / No. 3 | Open |
| 191 | |||||
| 1958 | Round of 32 Champ 32 | Dave Dunlop vs Ellis Jensen | Fall 2:32 | No. 1 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Adnan Al-Kaissy vs Dave Dunlop | Dec 8–4 | 0 · recorded zero / No. 1 | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Dick Kubes vs John Sullivan | Dec 4–1 | No. 4 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | George Adams vs Delmec Scales | Dec 3–2 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Jim Craig vs Bob Burge | Dec 6–0 | No. 6 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Ken Maidlow vs Gene White | Dec 3–2 | No. 3 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Pete Newell Sr. vs Vaughn Green | Dec 5–2 | No. 5 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Pete Veldman vs Lyle Brownlee | Dec 4–1 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Roger Pohlman vs Bob Lee | Dec 6–4 | No. 2 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | Adnan Al-Kaissy vs Pete Veldman | Dec 5–1 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | Ken Maidlow vs Jim Craig | Dec 3–2 | No. 3 / No. 6 | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | Pete Newell Sr. vs Dick Kubes | Fall 8:56 | No. 5 / No. 4 | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | Roger Pohlman vs George Adams | Dec 1–0 | No. 2 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Semifinal Champ 4 | Ken Maidlow vs Roger Pohlman | Dec 4–1 | No. 3 / No. 2 | Open |
| 1958 | Semifinal Champ 4 | Pete Newell Sr. vs Adnan Al-Kaissy | Dec 4–0 | No. 5 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Championship final 1st | Ken Maidlow vs Pete Newell Sr. | Fall 4:52 | No. 3 / No. 5 | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #1 | Jim Craig vs Gene White | Dec 5–1 | No. 6 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #1 | Vaughn Green vs Dick Kubes | Dec 2–0 | 0 · recorded zero / No. 4 | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #2 | Adnan Al-Kaissy vs Vaughn Green | Dec 2–1 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #2 | Jim Craig vs Roger Pohlman | Dec 1–0 | No. 6 / No. 2 | Open |
| 1958 | Third-place bout 3rd | Jim Craig vs Adnan Al-Kaissy | Dec 6–4 | No. 6 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| Unlimited | |||||
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Bob Norman vs Bob Steinke | Fall 7:36 | No. 1 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Dan Brand vs Marvin Kay | Fall 6:53 | No. 3 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Earl Lynn vs Herm Sieck | Dec 5–3 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Gordon Roesler vs Barron Bremner | Dec 4–3 | No. 2 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | John Baum vs William 'Pat' Lovell | Dec 2–2 | 0 · recorded zero / No. 4 | Open |
| 1958 | Round of 16 Champ 16 | Walter Goltl vs Joe Dougherty | Fall 5:55 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | Bob Norman vs Earl Lynn | Dec 8–3 | No. 1 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | Dan Brand vs Les Nader | Fall 7:19 | No. 3 / No. 6 | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | Dave Hanks vs John Baum | Dec 5–2 | No. 5 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Quarterfinal Champ 8 | Gordon Roesler vs Walter Goltl | Dec 4–0 | No. 2 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Semifinal Champ 4 | Bob Norman vs Dave Hanks | Dec 6–2 | No. 1 / No. 5 | Open |
| 1958 | Semifinal Champ 4 | Gordon Roesler vs Dan Brand | Dec 2–0 | No. 2 / No. 3 | Open |
| 1958 | Championship final 1st | Bob Norman vs Gordon Roesler | Dec 5–3 | No. 1 / No. 2 | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #1 | Earl Lynn vs Bob Steinke | Fall 5:46 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #1 | Walter Goltl vs Barron Bremner | Dec 3–0 | 0 · recorded zero / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #2 | Dan Brand vs Walter Goltl | Dec 5–3 | No. 3 / 0 · recorded zero | Open |
| 1958 | Consi 4 #2 | Earl Lynn vs Dave Hanks | Dec 7–3 | 0 · recorded zero / No. 5 | Open |
| 1958 | Third-place bout 3rd | Earl Lynn vs Dan Brand | Dec 3–2 | 0 · recorded zero / No. 3 | Open |